Reston Community Players have been honored by these organizations:
- Washington Area Theatre Community Honors (WATCH):
- 2007: (3 shows) 17 nominations and 3 awards for Outstanding Achievement
- 2006: 2 nominations and 1 award for Outstanding Achievement, Joseph and the Amazing Technicolor Dreamcoat
- 2005: (2 shows) 25 nominations and 8 awards for Outstanding Achievement, including Outstanding Musical, Disney's Beauty and the Beast
- 2004: (3 shows) 12 nominations and 1 award for Outstanding Achievement
- 2003: (4 shows) 23 nominations and 6 awards for Outstanding Achievement
- 2002: (3 shows) 20 nominations and 3 awards for Outstanding Achievement
- 2001: (4 shows) 12 nominations for Outstanding Achievement
- 2000: (2 shows) 14 nominations and 4 awards for Outstanding Achievement, including Outstanding Musical, A Chorus Line
- Ruby Griffith Award:
- 1997 Outstanding Achievement in a Play, Extremities
- 1994 Outstanding Achievement in a Musical, Into the Woods
- 1991 All-Round Production Excellence, A Midsummer Night's Dream
- 1989 All-Round Production Excellence (2nd Runner-Up), Godspell
- 1987 All-Round Production Excellence (1st Runner-Up), They're Playing Our Song
- 1981 All-Round Production Excellence (1st Runner-Up), The Man Who Came to Dinner
- NVTA One-Act Play Festival:
- 1996 Best Production, Fool for Love
- 1993 Best Production, Cat's-Paw
- 1992 Best Original Production, One Perfect Rose: Dorothy Parker
